Welcome to -What's Up Williamsburg- Your Local Community Resource

Casa Pearl

722 Merrimac Trail, Williamsburg, VA 23185, USA

About Casa Pearl

4.8 / 5

from reviews

    Casa Pearl focuses on quality locally-sourced ingredients, seasoned culinary expertise, and gracious customer service. Our raw bar features many of the delicious fish and shellfish that the Chesapeake Bay region has to offer. Tacos are Latin-inspired, but with a southern twist. The menu consists of smaller plates to encourage sharing.

    Yong Choi
    -
    December 01, 2025

    I absolutely love the atmosphere. The way they transformed a vehicle garage into such a nice, distinctive restaurant space is awesome and creative. Beyond the great interior, the food delivers: the fish was real good and tasted fresh. Highly recommended for a delicious meal in a unique setting!

    Heather Steinmiller
    -
    November 23, 2025

    We've been eating here since it opened in 2018 and it never fails to exceed expectations! The food is always extremely fresh, the staff are uniformly fabulous, and it's just a nice, uncomplicated, chill place to hang with friends while eating delicious food. Today our server was John and he went above and beyond the standard excellence of the servers - friendly & knowledgeable, even though his station was hopping. Always a solid choice for good eats. I had the ceviche (forgot the photo) and the crispy Brussels sprouts. Ceviche was light and refreshing, the sprouts tangy and crisp. Hubby had three different tacos - swordfish, pulled pork, and fried oysters. They disappeared very quickly. Our friends shared the day's fish special, charred sea bass over veg, also demolished quickly. Dessert was Key Lime trifle - we ordered one with four spoons and let's just say it didn't last long as we passed it around the table. Get there when they open to assure a seat as they do not take reservations. But I guarantee you will walk out with an extremely happy tummy!

    Mary-Ann L.
    -
    October 19, 2025

    Pricey but delicious so it’s worth it. Including the drive from VA Beach to get here. Cute part of town, seems like it’s a strip of Merrimac trail that has small quaint restaurants. I ordered their whole fish with chili oil. It was served with shaved fennel, rosemary, micro greens, Brussels sprouts. They serve the fish head and tail on, I enjoyed it very much since I get to debone the fish which was super fresh. $31 for a small fish! I ordered their oyster po boy taco which had 3 fried oysters served on two tortillas and fresh cabbage, etc. Both dishes had a tad bit too much lemon/citrus taste and after taste. I just wish the fried oysters were placed on top of the veggies and sauce so they could stay crunchy and not soggy! The service was great, my server was patient going through the menu since I indicated it was my first time dining with them, everyone seems to be polite.

    Hiba Damati
    -
    September 01, 2025

    Always exceptional. Easily the best fish tacos I’ve ever had. Everything is always delicious, from the dip, oysters, ceviche literally all appetizers. Best thing about this place is their consistency, we come here every single month and it’s always amazing!

    Ralphael Bell
    -
    July 01, 2025

    It was an amazing experience from the time my wife and I walked until we paid and left. The oysters were so good they were like a drug I couldn't put down. The food was so fresh and tasty. We will be going back and taking the kids next time. Casa Pearl is 10🌟 out of 5.

    Casa Pearl

    Our Address

    722 Merrimac Trail, Williamsburg, VA 23185, USA

    Interested In Getting More Customers?

    Leverage Your Listing With Our Coupon Mailer!

    Skip to content